Ramen Setagaya
141 First Ave
New York, NY
(212) 529-2740
What I ordered: ‘Cha-syu Tsuke-men Oomori’ or BBQ pork salt ramen with noodles served separately. I think the ‘oomori’ means deluxe which means I just got more noodles and/or broth. Assuming quality does not change with quantity, this review is applicable for all sizes of food.
With college still fresh in my mind, part of me is very against paying more than $0.99 for ramen. If I just got a paycheck or if I’m celebrating, I may move on to $1.99 ramen. And considering I know how to make good ramen, you better be giving me some damn good noodles if you want me to shell over 10+ bucks.
These were some pretty damn good noodles. I want to first start off by saying I had no clue what I ordered until it came out. Ramen in my mind has always been curly noodles in big hot bowl of tasty broth with some other random stuff tossed in. What I was given was a plate of almost fettuccine-like noodles (so flat instead of thin and round) next to a bowl of broth. The noodles kinda threw me off at first, but they taste fine. I didn’t know you could eat ramen like soba, but it works for me.
What went through my head after my first bite was “this tastes funny. . . kinda fishy.” Not like nasty fishy, but a flavorful fishy. It wasn’t until halfway through my meal I realized that the fishy flavor came from (drum-roll please) scallops in the broth. Let me repeat that: there were little scallops in my broth. Do you realize how amazing that is? Sure there’s crab/ lobster/ shrimp/ scallop/ insert expensive sea creature flavored instant ramen (usually part of my celebratory $1.99 ramen), but to actually get an expensive sea creature in my broth is a completely different story. Only thing I can compare this to is ordering salmon roe sushi and getting caviar instead of salmon roe. Slight misrepresentation of the “salt” broth, but if you want to substitute salt with dried scallops, by all means go ahead.
Flavorful goodness aside, I realized that if I want to order a HOT dipping dish, I should not sit directly under an air conditioner vent. Take moist noodles spread on a plate with their surface area all exposed like a exhibitionist and add stream of cold air. The result is freezing cold noodles due to evaporative cooling (and stiff nipples if I were to continue my exhibitionist comparison . . . which I am). I had a lot of noodles. 5 minutes into my meal I had a lot of cold noodles. Dipping a lot of cold noodles into a bowl of hot broth will reduce the temperature of the broth. So about 10 minutes into my meal, I had a lot of cold noodles and cold broth; probably not the way this dish was designed to be served and enjoyed. Although this series of unfortunate thermodynamic events reduced my overall enjoyment of my meal, it was still a delicious dish.
Conclusion: I would buy it even if I were not hungers . . . provided that I am not seated under an AC vent.